Consciousness and Freedom according to the Siva Sutras
Subhash C. Kak

Louisiana State University
Baton Rouge, LA 70803-5901, USA
FAX: 504.388.5200; Email: kak@ee.lsu.edu

More


July 22, 1997

Abstract
The logic of materialist science fails when observers are considered. How can inanimate matter, governed by fixed laws, lead to mind? To bring in consciousness as a separate category like space, time, and matter, as suggested by many physicists and neuroscientists, leads to further paradox. This very issue was considered with great subtlety in the Vedic tradition of India. Here we consider one of the late classics of this tradition that deals with the question of consciousness, laws, and freedom the justly famous Siva Sutras (c. 800 C.E.). We present a new translation of the Siva Sutras along with a commentary.


He became the original form of every form
It is his form that is everywhere to be seen.

-Rigveda 6.47.18

This paper presents a translation of the 78 aphorisms of the Siva Sutras 


Introduction

Our knowledge of the physical world is based on empirical associations and inductive generalizations. This process of knowledge accumulation has led to the discovery of the laws of the physical world. But how do we study the nature of consciousness, which cognizes the physical world, makes associations between empirical facts, and provides an a priori conceptual context for perception?

There is no way to observe one's own awareness because we become aware through the associations with the phenomenal world, which includes the ongoing processes in the brain. The Vedas deal precisely with this central question of the nature of knowledge. The consciousness aspect of the Vedas was emphasized most emphatically by Dayananda (1824-1883) and Aurobindo (1872-1950), and can be seen discussed with even greater directness in the Upanishads.

It has been less than a century that the theories of relativity and quantum physics have brought the observer centerstage in physics. It is not surprising, therefore, that the Vedic ideas, with their emphasis on cognition, should have been a source of enduring inspiration for many contemporary scientists. As is well known, the Vedic idea of brahman as a representation of all possibilities was the inspiration behind the conception of the quantum-mechanical wavefunction dened as the sum of all possibilities.

Few would deny that modern science has had great success in explaining the nature of the physical world. But these successes have not brought us any closer to the resolution of the mystery of consciousness behind those explanations. In the application of quantum theory to the macroworld and in the neuropsychological explorations of the brain, one can no longer ignore the question of the observer.

The notion that the mind emerges somehow out of the complexity of the connections inside the brain is too simplistic to be taken seriously. It puts us in the realm of Baron unchhausen, who pulled himself out of the bog by his own bootstraps! If mind emerges from matter, how does it obtain autonomy? If the world is governed by laws then how do we have free will? If our autonomy (free will) is an epiphenomenon, then are we walking shadows? Should one consider consciousness to be the ground-stuof reality? If so, then what is the connection between consciousness and the physical world?

These are precisely the questions that we come across repeatedly in the Indian traditions.

Is there something to be learnt from their insights.

The Aphorisms of Siva, or Siva Sutras (SS), are a late reiteration of the Vedic view of consciousness. According to one legend, Vasugupta (c. 800 C.E., Kashmir) saw the aphorisms (sutras) in a lucid dream. The Siva Sutras led to the owering of the Kashmiri schools of consciousness (Kashmir Saivism). It is due to its highly lucid exposition of the issues that Kashmir Saivism has come to be quite influential in contemporary scholarship.

This paper presents a translation, along with the Sanskrit text, of the 78 aphorisms of the SS. The number 78 has a very important signicance in the Vedic altar ritual: the earth altar is assigned the number 21, the atmosphere-altars the number 78, and the sky altar the number 261.

The supreme ritual is building the sky altar but this is done in a sequence which includes the other altars as well. Indra is an atmospheric god in the Vedas; he is lauded the most because he is the intermediary in the strivings to reach the sky or the heavens. In the

SS, Siva has replaced Indra as the intermediary. We know this happened when the naksatra Magha, representing the adhidavika aspect of Indra, stopped rising at vernal equinox due to the precession of the earth.

In order not to burden the reader with an unfamiliar vocabulary, and to provide a fresh view of the text, the commentary provided in this paper is not based on the commentatorial tradition from within Kashmir Saivism. I present my translation, as well as my commentary, in as modern terms as possible.

The Individual and the Universal in the Siva Sutras

The Vedic texts speak of two kinds of knowledge which may be described by the dichotomies individual (apara) and universal (para), ordinary and extraordinary, or lower and higher. According to SS ordinary knowledge comes from phenomenal associations. In other words, this knowledge can only be in terms of the associations of the outer world. But the associations in themselves need something to bind them together.

The binding energy is called matrka. It is matrka that makes it possible for us to understand words or symbols strung together as language. Lacking matrka, computers cannot understand language or images.

How do we reach universal knowledge starting from ordinary knowledge? Here SS begins with a description of universal consciousness, which, as a unity, is called Siva or Bhairava.

Siva makes it possible for the phenomenal associations of the physical world to have meaning. Nevertheless, the domain of the union of Siva and the phenomenal world is puzzling and astonishing (1.12). This astonishment becomes most acute as one switches from the consciousness of the enjoyer to that of the observer. How much of one's phenomenal self is the enjoyer and how much is the observer? How can these proportions be changed?

And what is the meaning of the transformation when these are changed?

The idea of the two minds is the restatement of a metaphor that goes back to the Rigveda 1.164.20 where the mind is likened to two birds sitting on a tree; one of them eats the sweet fruit while the other looks on without eating. One of the birds represents the universal consciousness while the other signifies the individual consciousness. In reality, there is only one bird; the second bird is just the image of the first energized by the fruit! There is a paradox here which is left unresolved. The resolution of this paradox is within the nature of root consciousness (Siva, prakasa, cit), which is what makes it possible for us to comprehend any meaning. Consciousness can also reflect on itself! In later texts this capacity is called vimarsa.

Another metaphor that has been used in the Vedic texts is that of the sun of consciousness illuminating the associations in the mind. This illumination is facilitated by icchasakti, the "power of the will;" Uma represents this sakti. As Uma illuminates specic associations, the subject becomes the enjoyer with respect to these associations. The subject ( Siva) becomes one with the ground stuof the associations (Uma). This is the union of Siva and Sakti that takes place continually, representing a unceasing process.

Innate knowledge is taken to emerge from the mind, which is equated with mantra, taken here not as a formula but the inherent capacity to re ect. Mantra merges into a apprehension" (saks . atkara) of the reality that lies beyond material associations.

Consider sound made meaningful in terms of strings that, as words, have specic associations. But what about the meaning" of elementary" sounds? The \elementary" sounds are the ones informed by the sakti underlying the senses. This sakti comes into play as one opens the crack" between the universal and the individual. The individual then enters a state where knowledge is the goal.

A detachment from associations is the key to the knowledge of the Self|the universal being. One is supposed to take oneself (i.e. one's psyche or mind) as an outsider! By separating the senses from their associations, one is able to reach to the heart of the Self.

The fourth state

The classication of consciousness into the three states of waking, dreaming, and deep sleep is an old one. Here it is claimed that the transcending fourth state, where one is creatively aware, can be experienced in any of the three states. Such a creative awareness is accompanied by insight and new connections. The experienced world has a structure but this structure can be comprehended only by the Self.

The mind

SS uses a striking image where the mind, embodied by various energies, seeks an existence in which knowledge is its food. The mind is the Self, but it must transcend its conditioned manifestation to be itself. But there are other questions. What we perceive as the outer reality is created by the mind. The universe is this dance which comes into form only when there is an observer. Unity engenders a polarity. The mind is dened as mantra. Since it enables the acquisition of knowledge, so it is energized by the breath of the eternal.

On transformation

Individual knowledge, in itself, cannot lead to higher knowledge, although it might be informed by it. The development of individual knowledge does, however, set up a process of self-transformation, which is described in Part 3 of SS. This process requires a calm mind and a reaching for the source of the cognitions. In this sense, the search for individual knowledge does facilitate the acquisition of universal knowledge.

This part addresses clearly how one transforms oneself from being the enjoyer" to the observer." But the self that emerges is an actor (3.9). Nevertheless, this does not mean that the individual's humanity is diminished. In fact, this allows for freedom and creativity (3.10). So the process of creativity is a manifestation of the universal. When separateness is gone, action can lead to creation" (3.37). It is asserted that the fourth (transcendental) state of consciousness should inform the lower states (such as waking, sleep, and deep sleep).Various wondrous attributes of the free person are described.

The mind and the body are coupled in a variety of ways. It is not surprising, therefore, that one can heighten the awareness of the mind through an awareness of the body. One must breathe properly (3.23). Likewise, by meditation on sounds and words one can separate and join perceptions (3.25).

 The Siva Sutras

1.

Universal consciousness

1.1

Consciousness is the Self.

1.2

(Ordinary) knowledge consists of associations.

1.3

Sets of axioms generate structures.

1.4

The ground of knowledge is matrka.

1.5

The upsurge (of consciousness) is Bhairava.

1.6

By union with the energy centers one withdraws from the universe.

1.7

Even during waking, sleep, and deep sleep one can experience the fourth state (transcending consciousness).

1.8

(Sensory) knowledge is obtained in the waking state.

1.9

Dreaming is free ranging of thoughts.

1.10

Deep sleep is maya, the irrational.

1.11

The experiencer of the three states is the Self.

1.12

The domain of the union is wonder.

1.13

The power of the will is the playful Uma.

1.14

The observed has a structure.

1.15

By fixing the mind on its core one can comprehend the perceivable and emptiness.

1.16

Or by contemplating the pure principle one is free of the power that binds (to associ-ations).

1.17

Right awareness is the knowledge of the Self.

1.18

Blissful sight is the goal of samadhi.

1.19

The body emerges when the energies unite.

1.20

Elements unite, elements separate, and the universe is gathered.

1.21

Pure knowledge leads to a mastery of the wheel (of energies).

1.22

The great lake (of space-time, of Self) is experienced through the power of mantra.

2. The emergence of innate knowledge

2.1 Mantra is the mind.

2.2 Effort leads to attainment.

2.3 The secret of mantra is the being in the body of knowledge.

2.4 The expansion of the mind in the womb is the forgetting of common knowledge.

2.5 When the knowledge of one's Self arises one moves in the sky of consciousness|the

Siva's state.

2.6 Guidance is essential (i.e., the guru is the means).

2.7 The awakening of the wheel of matr . ka (the binding energies).

2.8 The body is the oblation.

2.9 The food is knowledge.

2.10 With the extinction of knowledge emerges the vision of emptiness.

3. The transformations of the individual

3.1 The mind is the Self.

3.2 (Material) knowledge is bondage (limiting association).

3.3 Maya is the lack of discernment of the principles of transformation.

3.4 The transformation is retracted in the body.

3.5 By the quieting of the vital channels, the mastery of the elements, the withdrawal from

the elements, and the separation of the elements (is achieved).

3.6 Perfection is through the veil of delusion.

3.7 Overcoming delusion and by boundless extension innate knowledge is achieved.

3.8 Waking is the second ray (of consciousness).

3.9 The Self is the actor.

3.10 The inner Self is the stage.

3.11 The senses are the spectators.

3.12 The pure state is achieved by the power of the intellect.

3.13 Freedom (creativity) is achieved.

3.14 As here so elsewhere.

3.15 Emission (of consciousness) is the way of nature and so what is not external is seen as

external.

3.16 Attention to the seed.

3.17 Seated (in the highest power) one sinks eortlessly into the lake (of consciousness).

3.18The measure of consciousness fashions the world.

3.19As (limited) knowledge is transcended, birth is transcended.

3.20Maheshvari and other mothers (sources) of beings reside in the sound elements.

3.21The fourth (state of consciousness) should be used to oil the (other) three (states of

consciousness).

3.22Absorbed (in one's own nature), one must penetrate (the language) with one's mind.

3.23Balanced breathing leads to balanced vision.

3.24The lower plane arises in the center (of the language).

3.25What was destroyed rises again by the joining of perceptions with the objects of

experience.

3.26He becomes like Siva.

3.27The activity of the body is the vow.

3.28The recitation (of sounds) is the discourse.

3.29Self-knowledge is the boon.

3.30He who is established is the means and knowledge.

3.31For him the universe is the aggregate of his powers.

3.32Persistence and absorption.

3.33Even when (there is) this (maintenance and dissolution) there is no break (in awareness)

due to the perceiving subjectivity.

3.34The feeling of pleasure and pain is external.

3.35The one who is free of that is alone (conscious).

3.36(Owing to) a mass of delusion, the mind is subject to activity.

3.37 When separateness is gone, action can lead to creation.

3.38The power to create is based on one's own experience (of the Self).

3.39That which precedes the three (states of consciousness) vitalizes them.

3.40The same stability of mind (should permeate) the body, the senses and the external

world.

3.41Craving leads to the extroversion of the inner process.

3.42When established in pure awareness, (the craving) is destroyed and the (empirical)

individual ceases to exist.

3.43Although cloaked in the elements one is not free, but, like the lord, one is supreme.

3.44The link with the vital breath is natural.

3.45(The breath is stilled by) concentrating on the center at the top (within the nose); of what use (then) are the left and the right channels or susumna?

3.46May (the individual) merge (in the lord) once again!


Concluding Remarks

This brief paper is just an introduction for the layperson or the cognitive scientist to the riches of the Kashmir school of consciousness. The contents of SS are very cryptic and one

may not be convinced that it represents any advance over the ancient Upanishadic tradition. But later texts speak of important details in the process of cognition. The structure of the Kashmir school of consciousness goes beyond the categories of Sa nkhya. I hope that others will examine other classics in this tradition and see for themselves whether it has any lessons for contemporary science; further connections between modern science and this tradition are being investigated by several scholars.

Sanskritists who have worked on Indian theories of consciousness have been ignorant of the important insights of modern physics relating to the process of observation. The argument that one need not know contemporary insights since they were unknown when the old texts were written is just plain wrong. This argument is based on the assumption that the sages operated in the milieu of materialist physics, and if they did not, they ought to have! But materialist physics is a relatively modern paradigm that may be traced back to Newton and Leibnitz. Modern science has helped liberate analysis from the straitjacket of this reductionist logic. So why shouldn't one take advantage of modes of thought which are close to the logic of the visions of the sages of the old?

Schrodinger's use of Vedic insights is testimony to the fact that the metaphors in use by the ancient thinkers were holistic and similar to that of modern physics. But do we need to go beyond even this? Can the process of meditation on the nature of consciousness lead to insights that remain beyond the pale of our current scientic" understanding of the nature of reality?

Kashmir Saivism deals with concepts that also have a bearing on other questions: How do the senses emerge in the emergence of the mind? Could there be more senses than we possess? The whole mythology of Siva is a retelling of the astonishing insights of the science of consciousness. But just as matter coalesces into a variety of substances according to laws (rta), can we nd the laws of the manifestation of the Self through the various senses and the mind?

Do the Vedic texts and the tantras only describe the various levels of this manifestation, or are these laws to be found too? Will there be a convergence in the languages of myth and science?

Acknowledgement

I acknowledge the comments made on earlier versions of this paper by Georg Feuerstein.

Notes

1. For an overview of the Vedic tradition, see the recent book coauthored by me (Feuerstein et al, 1995); this book summarizes new insights from archaeology and history of

science.

2. Moore, 1989; Kak, 1995b.

3. Kak, 1995a-b, 1996a-c.

4. For earlier translations, see Jaideva Singh (1979) and Dyczkowski (1992). Note that Jaideva Singh has 77 sutras whereas Dyczkowski has 79; for the reason why the canonical text is likely to have had 78 sutras, see Kak (1994).

5. Kak, 1994, 1995c.

6. This is the binding problem of neuroscience to which no solution, within the reductionist paradigm, is known; see Kak, 1995a for details.

7. Uma is the dual to Siva representing vitality and energy.

8. E.g. Abhinavagupta, 1987, 1989; Dyczkowski, 1987.

9. Kramrisch, 1981.

 

References

Abhinavagupta, 1987. Tantraloka. With the Commentary Viveka of Jayaratha, R.C.

Dwivedi and N. Rastogi (eds.). Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi.

Abhinavagupta, 1989. A Trident of Wisdom. State University of New York Press, Albany.

Dyczkowski, M.S.G., 1987. The Doctrine of Vibration. State University of New York Press,

Albany.

Dyczkowski, M.S.G., 1992. The Aphorisms of Siva: The SivaSutra with Bhaskara's Commentary, the Varttika. State University of New York Press, Albany.

Feuerstein, G., Kak, S.C., Frawley, D., 1995. In Search of the Cradle of Civilization. Quest Books, Wheaton, IL.

Kak, S.C., 1992/4. Re ections in clouded mirrors: selfhood in animals and machines. Presented at the Symposium on Aliens, Apes, and Articial Intelligence: Who is a person in the postmodern world? Southern Humanities Council Annual Conference, February 13, 1993. Also in Learning and Self-Organization, Karl Pribram and Joseph King (editors), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ, 1996, pp. 511-534.

Kak, S.C., 1994. The Astronomical Code of the R . gveda. Aditya, New Delhi.

Kak, S.C., 1995a. Quantum neural computing. Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, vol 94, 259-313.

Kak, S.C., 1995b. The three languages of the brain: quantum, reorganizational, and associative. 4th Appalachian Conf. on Behavioral Neurodynamics, Radford, VA, September. Also in Learning and Self-Organization, Karl Pribram and Joseph King (editors),

Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ, 1996, pp. 185-219,13

Kak, S.C., 1995c. The astronomy of the age of geometric altars. Q. J. R. astr. Soc., 36, 385-396.

Kak, S.C., 1996a. Information, physics, and computation. Foundations of Physics, 26, 127-137.

Kak, S.C., 1996b. Speed of computation and simulation. Foundations of Physics, 26, 1375-1386.

Kak, S.C., 1996c. Why machines cannot be conscious. Presented at Towards a Science of Consciousness, TUCSON II, Tucson, April 8-13.

Kramrisch, S., 1981. The Presence of Siva. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Moore, W., 1989. Schrodinger: Life and Thought. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Singh, Jaideva, 1979. Siva Sutras: The Yoga of Supreme Identity. Motilal Banarsidass,

Delhi.

In PDF Format


Buy Siva Sutra

 



"I have spent innumerable hours on the Beezone site and I found it to be an invaluable and nearly essential resource for perusal of the most comprehensive array of spiritually varied topics and discussions to be found anywhere on the Internet. This is often times where the curious starts their process."
Beezone visitor

 

  Adi Da, Ramana Maharshi, Nityananda, Shridi Sai Baba, Upasani Baba,  Seshadri Swamigal , Meher Baba, Sivananda, Ramsuratkumar
"The perfect among the sages is identical with Me. There is absolutely no difference between us"
Tripura Rahasya, Chap XX, 128-133

 

..

Facebook...

...
.....Forum


 
Beezone a nonprofit (501(c)3) educational foundation

All copyright materials are used under authority of the
Fair Use statute and United State Code, Title 17

.