The Inaccessible Place: The Transformative Heart of Duality
by Beezone, Ed Reither, and ChatGPT
***
“The one-after-another is a bearable prelude to the deeper knowledge of the side-by-side, for this is an
incomparably more difficult problem. Again, the view that good and evil
are spiritual forces outside us, and that man is caught in the conflict
between them, is more bearable by far than the insight that the opposites
are the ineradicable and indispensable preconditions of all psychic life”
Mysterium Coniunctionis, Carl Jung
Preface
The genesis of this essay lies in my exploration of the works of Carl Gustav Jung and Edward Edinger, two significant figures in depth psychology and the study of the human psyche. While studying Jung’s Mysterium Coniunctionis: An Inquiry into the Separation and Synthesis of Psychic Opposites in Alchemy, particularly the section titled “The Opposites,” I became intrigued by his analysis of dualities and their role in psychological transformation based on my earlier studies in Mahayana Buddhism. Jung’s exploration of alchemical symbols as metaphors for the individuation process—the journey toward integrating the unconscious and conscious aspects of the self (although a bit too alchemical jargon) planted the seeds for this essay.
Edward Edinger’s lecture further kindled my reading of Jung’s Individuation: A Myth for Modern Man, delivered in 1988 at the C.G. Jung Institute of Los Angeles. In this lecture, Edinger delved into the central Jungian myth of individuation, describing it as a lifelong process of connecting with the self—the archetype of wholeness—and integrating the numinous “God-image” within the psyche. He emphasized the transformative power of mythological and religious symbols, which serve as bridges between the ego and the self. This synthesis of Jung and Edinger’s insights brought into focus the transformative middle—the space where opposites meet, dissolve, and give birth to new realities, bringing my Buddhist studies to the fore.
As I immersed myself in these studies, I was reawakened to the limitations of ‘the mind,’ and the tools psychologists, philosophers, and pandits of various scientific and artistic fields use to try to understand the dynamic interplay of dualities, the “twoness” of the Cosmos.
My earlier studies and practices in Buddhism brought me to a “place” beyond duality, as alluded to in the Heart Sutra with its mantra, “Gate gate, paragate, parasamgate, bodhi svaha,” which became a central theme in my understanding. This transformative middle, inaccessible to reason yet vital to creation, destruction, and renewal, along with my studies, emerged as the heart of this essay and a ‘message,’ a kind of warning.
The essay that follows is an attempt to articulate this ineffable “place” and its significance across disciplines, from physics and psychology to mysticism and mythology. It examines the dangers of egoic attempts to dominate one side of duality while ignoring the other, as illustrated in Goethe’s Faust and The Sorcerer’s Apprentice. Ultimately, the essay seeks to point toward the realization—not intellectual comprehension—that underlies the unity of opposites, a realization that aligns with the wisdom of the Heart Sutra and the dynamic harmony of the universe itself.
This essay is both an exploration and an invitation: an exploration of the interplay of opposites and the transformative middle, and an invitation to reflect on the profound mystery of existence that lies beyond the grasp of our tools and concepts. May this inquiry serve as a stepping stone for those drawn to the transformative heart of duality and the path of individuation.
The human experience is steeped in duality. We perceive the world as pairs of opposites: light and dark, on and off, life and death. Yet, these opposites are not isolated; they are dynamically interrelated. Between them lies a “place,” a transformative middle that eludes our conventional tools of understanding—observation, language, or mathematics. This “place” is the essence of transformation, the silent engine of creation, sustaining, and dissolution.
The Essay
The Inaccessible Place: The Transformative Heart of Duality
Duality is the framework through which we navigate reality. From the binary code underpinning computers to the wave-particle duality of quantum physics, the universe appears to operate within the dance of opposites. Each aspect of duality defines and requires its counterpart:
- Light and Dark: Darkness gives meaning to light; without one, the other cannot be perceived.
- On and Off: In computing, the binary state of 1 and 0 creates infinite complexity.
- Birth and Death: Each new beginning implies an eventual end, and every end paves the way for a new beginning.
This interdependence is pervasive and undeniable. However, duality alone cannot explain the dynamic processes of change and emergence. Something more is at work—a transformative principle that lies between the two.
The Third: A Dynamic and Inaccessible Place
What might be called a “third” element exists between the poles of duality. This third is not a static entity but a process, a field, or an event that unites and transforms opposites. Importantly, it cannot be directly accessed or comprehended by conventional means.
- Inseparability from Opposites:
- The third is not separate from duality but arises from it. It is the relational dynamic that makes transformation possible. Without duality, there would be no interplay, no emergence.
- Limits of Understanding:
- Tools like observation and symbolic systems (e.g., language and mathematics) fail to capture this place. The same duality binds these tools they seek to explore. Just as a fish cannot conceive of the water it swims in, our dualistic frameworks cannot apprehend the transformative middle.
- Realization Beyond Thought:
- This place is accessible only through realization, a direct and intuitive knowing. The Heart Sutra’s mantra—”Gate gate, paragate, parasamgate, bodhi svaha”—points to this transition. The mantra speaks of moving beyond, further beyond, to a state of awakening that transcends dualistic perception.
The Middle as Transformation
This transformative place is not a “thing” but a process of becoming. It is where opposites meet and transmute into something entirely new. Examples abound across disciplines:
- Physics:
- In quantum mechanics, the wave-particle duality resolves only in the act of observation—a moment of transformation where potential becomes actual.
- Alchemy:
- The alchemical process of coniunctio unites opposites to create the philosopher’s stone. The middle stage, where dissolution and coagulation occur simultaneously, is the site of transformation.
- Mysticism:
- Mystics across traditions describe a “void” or “emptiness” where opposites dissolve. This is not a nihilistic emptiness but a fertile ground for emergence.
The Heart Sutra and the Nature of the Middle
The Heart Sutra’s mantra encapsulates the essence of this transformative place. The repetition of “Gate” (gone) emphasizes the movement beyond duality. The final state, bodhi svaha, signifies awakening or realization. This realization is not a conceptual understanding but an experiential knowing of the unity behind opposites.
- Gone Beyond:
- The mantra implies a progressive journey—first leaving behind conventional understanding, then transcending even the transcendence.
- Realization, Not Comprehension:
- The transformative place is not “understood” in the intellectual sense but “realized” through direct experience. It is the intuitive insight that duality is not ultimate but provisional, a stage in the process of becoming.
The Dangers of Ego and the Illusion of Control
This transformative middle cannot be commanded or controlled, yet the human ego often attempts to dominate one side of the duality while excluding the other. Goethe’s Faust and The Sorcerer’s Apprentice illustrate the peril of such hubris. The apprentice’s invocation of spirits—”spirits that I’ve cited / my commands ignore”—demonstrates the chaos unleashed when the ego seeks to harness one force while disregarding its counterpart. When one reaches this “level of the game,” where creation and destruction are at stake, the ego ventures into what can only be called God’s turf. The stakes are high, and any attempt to control these transformative forces can lead to profound imbalance. However, if one aligns with the deeper realization pointed to by the Heart Sutra, the Heart of the Universe will rule, guiding the process beyond the ego’s grasp.
- Hubris of Control:
- The ego’s attempt to control or isolate one side of a duality, such as light over dark or creation over destruction, inevitably invites imbalance. The repressed or ignored opposite resurfaces with greater force, disrupting the intended order.
- Lessons from Myth and Literature:
- The apprentice’s plight reminds us that true mastery involves humility and respect for the whole of duality. Transformation arises not through domination but through integration.
- Transcending the Ego:
- To navigate the transformative middle, one must relinquish the ego’s desire for control and embrace the paradoxical unity of opposites. This surrender allows for the realization of the dynamic interplay at the heart of existence.
Living the Middle
To live in awareness of this transformative place is to embrace paradox and uncertainty. It requires:
- Letting Go of Control:
- The desire to isolate, define, or control one pole of duality inevitably reinforces the other. Transformation occurs only when we surrender to the process.
- Cultivating Intuition:
- Intuition, or direct insight, becomes the guiding principle. Practices like meditation, contemplation, and artistic creation can open the door to this realization.
- Seeing the Whole:
- Recognizing that dualities are not contradictions but complements leads to a deeper understanding of unity in diversity.
Conclusion: The Mystery of the Third
The “place” between dualities is the heart of transformation and manifestation. It cannot be isolated, controlled, or fully understood. It is a dynamic process, a living paradox, and the source of all creation. By moving beyond dualistic frameworks and embracing realization, we come closer to the truth expressed in the Heart Sutra: that the ultimate nature of reality is not found in opposites but in their inseparable unity, the ever-unfolding middle where transformation occurs.
Study more: